Inspiration or Infringement?

| 1 Comment

Last year, the son of photographer Guy Bourdain sued Madonna claiming that the video for the song "Hollywood" infringed on Bourdain's copyrighted photography, because the video adopted a similar style to Bourdain's noir photos. They settled earlier this month.

Now, lets look at some robots. Low Culture suggests, Twentieth Century Fox, meet award-winning director Chris Cunningham and notes that the visual style of the upcoming film I, Robot (based on the Isaac Asimov book) is visually similar to the video for Bjork's song All is Full of Love.

2004_06_doubletaking-thumb.jpg

Should this kind of visual homage be considered a type of copyright infringement? If so, how much style comprises an expression, rather than an idea?

(via Gothamist)

1 Comment

if so, then chris cunningham should himself go meet mamoru oshii and talk shop. not that i didnt love the bjork video. i think it should be taken as homage...because imagery and influences always straddle fuzzy boundaries.

!h

About

A work in progress

Recent Entries

The best fan video in the world?
Via Top Gear's blog, I found this link to a fan-made Top Gear style search for the beat driving road…
Shatner, Montalban, iPod and Kindle
Dvice tests out the range of expression in the text-to-speech systems in the Kindle 2 and iPod Shuffle by having…
A F#*&ing brilliant Supreme Court ruling?
The Supreme Court released its ruling in FCC v. Fox Television Stations, et al. (07-582), in which a 5-4 majority…